This has been one of the hottest summers on record where I live and I have one window ac unit the can’t quite keep up. Which is why I have found myself at a local movie theater on their weekly discount day to just sit in that sweet sweet ac.
I actually can not remember a time that I ever went to this many movies in one summer and the majority of my core group of my friends in high school all ended up going to film school.
So as a full grown adult with bills and opinions about loyalty programs, I bought a refillable cup at the movie theater.
But not before I did the math first to make sure that I would “beat” the cost of the cup based on the number of movies I had left to see before the promotion ran out of course like any good marketing person trying to think like the ideal audience.
Not refillable in the vague, marketing-copy sense. Refillable in the actual, physical, "bring this exact cup back clean and we'll fill it up again for a couple bucks" sense. It's this oversized plastic thing with the theater's logo on it, already a little scuffed, and after I clean it it lives on the bench by the door waiting for our next movie outing together.
That cup is the whole loyalty program- because I am not a member of the loyalty program. No app. No account. No phone number typed in at the register. I just show up with the cup, and whoever's behind the counter fills it up, checks me out and waves me on.
If I lose it, that's on me. If I bring it, I get the deal. That's the entire system.
I did not expect a plastic cup to make me feel something. And yet it has.
Because what's hilarious: that cup does everything a modern loyalty program is trying to do. It gets me back in the door week after week. It makes me feel like I’m getting something the regular ticket-buyer isn't. It turned a single transaction into a running relationship between me and that specific theater, all summer long.
And it does it without ever asking who I am.
Nobody needed my name to fill that cup. Nobody needed my email, my birthday, or a phone number to text me about "exclusive summer savings."
The cup itself was the credential.
You had it, or you didn't. The loyalty lives in a piece of plastic sitting in a cupholder, not in a database somewhere collecting information about how often I chose between coke and coke zero or popocorn or pretzel bites.
It's such a simple and throwback idea that it almost feels naive to bring up now.
Of course a business can build loyalty without collecting data. We used to do it all the time.
Anyone remember the Pepsi points and the catalog of stuff you could get with your UPC points and they guy who saved enough to get a Pepsi jet? If you don’t remember, don’t worry there’s a documentary .
But somewhere between 1996, the cup and the UPC’s became an app
and I don't think anyone sat down and decided physical loyalty was outdated. It just sort of got replaced, piece by piece, the way most things do now. The punch card became a phone number at checkout. The phone number became an app. The app became an app with notifications, and location and income tracking, and a feed of "personalized offers" you didn't ask for.
Each step probably felt like an improvement at the time. More data, better targeting, smarter personalization. And a lot of it genuinely is more convenient, when it works, and when you actually wanted the app in the first place.
But somewhere in there, the tradeoff changed. That cup asks nothing of me except to remember to bring it. The apps that replaced it are asking for a lot more, and a lot of people are starting to notice.
Here's the part I keep coming back to: I love the cup and it works because the reward is immediate, physical, crisp, bubbly and obvious. You could hold it in your hand. You didn't need to trust that points were accumulating correctly in some backend system, or hope a coupon code would actually apply at checkout. The theater fills the cup, right in front of me, every single time I hand it over.
A lot of digital loyalty programs have lost that. The reward is abstract. The trust is one-directional — you hand over data now, on the promise of a benefit later, administered by a system you can't see into. That's a much bigger ask than "bring the cup back."
Now I’m not saying every business needs to hand out plastic cups again, although honestly, some of them probably should. I’m merely suggesting that it's worth asking what the cup version of your loyalty program would look like. What's the simplest, most tangible way you could reward someone for coming back, without needing to know anything about them except that they showed up?
Somewhere out there, a version of one of your customers is deciding, right now, whether a business is worth trusting with their information and unsubribing from the loyalty program (if they even can). And a lot of the time, the answer is no — not because they don't want the deal, but because the deal isn't the cup anymore. It's a lot more spam and breached data for a lot less obvious of a reward.
I’m not saying convenience is the enemy. The refillable cup is convenient too. But it is convenient in a way that didn't cost anyone anything they weren't willing to give. That's the part worth bringing back to make you accessible to all.
If you're trying to figure out what the cup equivalent looks like for your business, that's a conversation I’m always up for.
